In response to the other emails on this appalling video...I was shocked to see it 
while it almost looks like a 'set up' video however I am certain that there are 
photographers that are that insensitive and that unethical in their pursuit of 
the photo, which makes it difficult for those of us who are ethical and careful 
because we get judged as "one of THOSE photographers".  
BUT let me ask this ethical question, to stir the pot even more, is what the 
photographers did, so different than what  some birders do as they pursue the 
birds to add one more check mark to their list and end up disturbing the birds?  

When you look at birds we have had on our own list-serve that were unusual to 
Missouri but stayed for several weeks, their every move was on the list and as 
a result, their feeding/resting time was constantly disturbed by birders wanting 
a glimpse of it.  So it was constantly being flushed from its varying places.  
How is this different, ethically, than what the photographers did with the 
Snowy?  Each bird was flushed by people wanting a closer look.  The 
photographers exercised inexcusable behavior but suppose they had no idea 
what they were doing was unethical? does that change anything?  As Edge put 
forth, how do you educate others and I say, the birding/photography 
community as well.

The point is, there are some unethical birders and there are some unethical 
photographers;sometimes, they are one and the same.  We are each, 
responsible for our behavior and our ethics.  Anytime these ethical dilemmas are 
put to the forefront of discussions, as gentle reminders of where our obsessions 
must end and ethical, moral responsibility must take over, is a good thing.

Perhaps on this list serve is a good place to review the ethics of birding, as has 
been done abit in the recent past.  I know there are some birding places that 
do not post the positions of certain birds such as owls and other rare species 
so there is less chance of disturbance, perhaps that is something the powers  
might re-consider on this list-serve. 

We all have an ethical and moral responsibility to protect the species that we 
are all enthralled with, to whatever degree that needs to be done, to ensure 
their survival in an ever fragile environment, this includes both birders AND 

Carol Weston
Columbia, MO
[log in to unmask]

The Audubon Society of Missouri's Wild Bird Discussion Forum
List archives: