Print

Print


Can someone tell me how to unsubscribe to this list please? thanks!




At 07:11 AM 9/4/01 -0400, Rickard Parker wrote:
>Tom K. wrote:
>
>> I still don't see how Julius reconciles the fact that Wagner thinks Jews
>in
>> Western societies cannot write as anything but Jews, while Eliot thinks it
>> "miraculous" when they do precisely that.
>>
>> Passing for the moment on their respective merits, the difference between
>> these position seems so obvious to me, I am baffled by Julius' suggestion
>> that they are in the same ballpark.
>
>I can't figure it out either.  I think, that as a writer of a book about his
>own thoughts, it was up to Julius to supply them.
>
>It is hardly worth the effort to determine what an anonymous writer might be
>thinking here.  To attempt to conclude what a named author is thinking from
>this in a way that he can be held to it is a total waste of time.  Maybe
>Julius makes more sense elsewhere (but I'm not going to bother searching for
>that section any time soon.)
>
>Regards,
>   Rick Parker
>
>
>