Your analogies are unfairt Carrol. No one is suggesting the suppression of
or a completely chaotic use of spelling. To say that sound should drive
and not the reverse is not to advocate chaos. Besides, who reads in the
----- Original Message -----
From: "Carrol Cox" <[log in to unmask]>
To: <[log in to unmask]>
Sent: Tuesday, April 04, 2006 6:45 AM
Subject: Re: 'Tyger' and 'Vrka' (Was: 'Mind forged menacles' and spelling )
> Peter Montgomery wrote:
> > Transpose your question to Elizabethan times (where I live) and
> > think of the effect of all the different spelling possibilities that
> > pened then (how many ways did Shakespare spell his name).
> > I suspect it used to be sound that drove spelling, not spelling, sound.
> > Today homogenised spelling has put sound in a straight jacket.
> A couple decades ago 1000s in South Africa were risking death,
> imprisonment, or worse to demand that English continue to be taught in
> Black schools. Why? Because English was the common language of those
> resisting the brutal occupation of their land by Europeans. Teaching the
> local language only in each school would would have been one route to
> atomizing and stifling the literation struggle.
> Most on this list have probably at one time or another ridden in someone
> else's car after dark and had the experience of frustrated groping for
> the door handle when they were getting out. Perhaps some have also been
> irritated by different combinations to control water volume or
> temperature in the bathrooms of different hotels and homes. Or struggle
> to find the green beans they have been buying for years among the 12
> different slight variations currently on the shelves for each brand
> name. If time is life, then these innumerable "possibilities" among
> which one must choose eat one's life away.
> It is childish when considering variability vs standardization to assume
> that all standarization leads to unfreedom, all multiplicity of
> possibility leads to freedom.
> No virus found in this incoming message.
> Checked by AVG Free Edition.
> Version: 7.1.385 / Virus Database: 268.3.5/300 - Release Date: 4/3/2006